Articles Questions

Updated September 29, 2022

Do We Have to Re-Do All Software System Tests After a Minor Change?

Dr. Oliver Eidel

Question

We’ve certified and released the first version of our software as a medical device. Now we’re working on a minor update which just fixes some bugs. Do we have to re-do all our software system tests before we can release it? This could be very painful because our testing process involved lots of manual tests.

Short Answer

No, not necessarily. Only re-do the tests for software requirements which were touched by the (code) change. But be sure to document your reasoning.

Long Answer

If only a small part of your code has been changed since your last release, you can just go ahead and check which software requirements and tests are affected by it. Only re-run those. But write down your reasoning somewhere, e.g. in your test plan, where you describe which tests don’t have to be re-done and why.

This is assuming that those tests were on a small (e.g. unit) level. Regarding your integration tests, I’d re-run those to ensure that you haven’t inadvertently broken something. This should be an easy win because your integration tests are usually automated (they are, right?).

The main point of this is to minimize unnecessary human (manual) testing if it’s not necessary.

But this is yet another topic which heavily depends on your auditor. When in doubt, I’d suggest that you make a proposal (write a test plan as described above), send it to them and ask them if that approach would be okay. They aren’t allowed to provide consulting to you but they should be able to give you an indication on whether you can move ahead with your approach or whether it needs more work.

See also my article on software system testing and the software system test plan template.

On a slighty different note: You want to get your medical software certified under MDR but don't know where to start? No worries! That's why we built the Wizard. It's a self-guided software which helps you create your documentation yourself, for only 149€ / month. No prior knowledge required. You should check it out.

Or, if you're looking for some human help, did you know that we also provide consulting, often guiding startups from start to finish in their medical device compliance?

And there's so much more: If you're looking for the best QMS software ever, look no further. We've built Formwork, and it's free!

Congratulations! You read this far.

Get notified when we post something new.

Sign up for our free newsletter.

Dr. Oliver Eidel

I'm a medical doctor, software engineer and regulatory dude. I've helped 50+ companies with their medical device compliance. I mainly work as a regulatory consultant, but my goal is to make consulting unnecessary by publishing all of our articles and templates for free :)

If you're still lost and have further questions, just send me an email. Read more about me here.

Digital Health Jobs No Cookie For You Privacy Policy Imprint
No QMS on this planet will save you from creating crappy software.