Machine Learning Software as a Medical Device: Can We Update Our Model?

Anonymous Technical Documentation Updated May 07, 2024 AI , Machine Learning
We’re developing machine learning - based software as a medical device. We’ve learned that once you’ve got a certified on the market, you need to get approval by your notified body before releasing significant changes. Now our question is: How does this relate to our machine learning model? Can we update it? Is that a significant change?

1 Answer

Accepted answer
Dr. Oliver Eidel
Dr. Oliver Eidel Founder & CEO, OpenRegulatory
Generally speaking, most Notified Bodies don't classify a machine learning model update as a significant change if your performance improves and your model architecture remains the same. You need to re-do your verification of your new model (e.g. do some testing with a test set and document the results). Active learning models which change their weights during deployment are currently not allowed.

Long Answer

Regulation and notified bodies are only slowly catching up with machine learning - based software. There’s no official standard or guidance so far (is that a good thing?) so my answer is entirely based on my experience with auditors.

An update of your machine learning model, i.e. an update of its weights, is generally not seen as a significant change. You need to re-do the verification of your ML model and store it internally.

This makes sense, because your ML model architecture stays the same and the performance has probably improved - so there probably aren't huge risks involved.

As there's no official guidance on this yet, you'll have to confirm with your auditor whether this process works with them.

If you change the architecture of your ML model, you may face more scrutiny but just be sure to prove that the decision made sense, your performance hasn’t gotten worse and you haven’t made the risk profile of your software worse.
Want to add your answer to this question?
Write an answer under your name by logging in or signing up, or post anonymously.

Still have a question? Ask a question here publicly - for free!

Or would you like to talk to one of our consultants? First calls are free. Check out our services and prices here.

And if you're looking to automate your regulatory work, check out our eQMS, Formwork. It's for lean, founder-led companies. It automates your compliance, and there's even a free version for you to try out!